Online since 1997 What Went Wrong?: Western Impact and Middle Eastern ResponseClick on a title to get information such as reviews, price comparisons, and availability or to purchase. Search Again-Enter Keyword, Title, or ISBN: |
|
What Went Wrong?: Western Impact and Middle Eastern Response
by: Bernard Lewis |
||
 |
|
or |
|
Binding: Hardcover Dewey Decimal Number: 956.015 EAN: 9780195144208 ISBN: 0195144201 Label: Oxford University Press Manufacturer: Oxford University Press Number Of Items: 1 Number Of Pages: 180 Publication Date: 2001-12 Publisher: Oxford University Press Studio: Oxford University Press |
||
| Customer Reviews | ||
  - The standard answer is ignored!This book is chock full of interesting facts, but as other reviewers have pointed out, the author fails to answer the question in his title: What went wrong? The strange thing about this is that there is an answer that is usually given to this question, so it is mystery why he doesn't discuss it. That answer is that the thinker al-Ghazali argued against philosophy (and science) and made revelation much more important than reason and that his influence was powerful enough to send a chill into the Muslim world for the next several centuries. I don't know enough to know whether that answer is right or not, and I welcome responses from anyone who can shed light on it. Rating: - Lewis Recrosses Familiar TurfBernard Lewis is the preeminent contemporary Western scholar of Islam (at least in its Middle Eastern manifestation). As such, he has previously written extensively and authoritatively on the interaction of the Middle East and the Western world (most notably in The Muslim Discovery of Europe and The Middle East and the West). Unfortunately, this book doesn't really build on these earlier works, offering minimal new information or noteworthy analysis. Lewis sets things up with long-established fact that during Europe's "Dark Ages," the Middle East was a booming intellectual center, preserving the knowledge of the Greeks. However, since this high point, the region has been in a steady decline in power and status relative to the West. Lewis positions this long-term, ongoing "what went wrong?" decline as the central "problem" of the modern Middle East. Moreover, he says, it is has for too long been framed by Middle Easterners in the form of the unhelpful question "Who did this to us?" (ie. the British, Americans, Zionists, etc.). He suggests that it is only very recently that some in the region are discarding this mindset and replacing it with the question, "What did we do wrong?" In other words, the abandonment of victimhood and the assumption of responsibility. The book then goes on to sketch Ottoman/Western interactions from the 16th-century on, showing how increased Western curiosity about the East (and economic interest) led them to travel widely in the East and establish various semi-permanent settlements there (such as merchant houses and embassies). He also discusses relatively obscure but interesting notions, such as the psychological ease with which Christian visitors could travel in Muslim versus the correspondingly theologically thorny "problem" of Muslims traveling among and settling in Christian lands. Similarly, Westerners were keen to master the languages of the East, and had educational systems which facilitated this, whereas in the East, the practice was to rely on a translators class (often Greeks). The overall effect was one whereby the West was able to rapidly absorb the learning of the East, while the East was no nearly as able (or psychologically willing) to take advantage of advances made in the West. Lewis's aim is more descriptive than prescriptive, and while these details are interesting, the broad picture is one that's been painted before. Namely, that the historic inability of Muslim civilizations to separate secular and religious spheres of life hampered their ability to absorb beneficial aspects of Western culture and learning. So, if you've read Lewis' earlier works, this one is unlikely to add much to your understanding of Muslim/Western relations. Rating:  - WWW!!!This book gives harsh reality about Middle east.I believe he gave his best answer for "What Went Wrong?". He is very informative. I enjoyed his point of view. One of my favorite sentence "Europeans managed to create a Christianity without compassion, so did some Middle Easterners create a democracy without freedom." Rating: - Outstanding.Required reading for a summer course at Hopkins; Lewis seems to have done it again. Some novel (to me, at least) outlooks, everything backed up flawlessly, trenchant insights. Rating: - everyone should get aquinted with this book.this is well written and really is helpful in understanding the roots of the problem caused by 911. the author obiously knowws what he is talking about and has the credentials and credibility to go along with it. he is the most knowledgable in the subject in current times. it really is sad that most americans can tell you who won a reality show but they cantell you of the roots of a war that they are fighting and losing thier children to! |
||